Category Archives: Mauna Kea

UH Board of Regents Accepts Responsibility for Mauna Kea CMP

On Friday, the University of Hawai‘i Board of Regents officially accepted the responsibility of implementing the Comprehensive Management Plan for taking care of Mauna Kea. They also appointed two Regents to sit ex-officio on the Mauna Kea Management Board. This is great news for those who want to be assured that management of Mauna Kea be done on the local level.

And in the legislature, conferees from the House and the Senate, who will reconcile HB 1174, HD3 SD2, the rule making bill that enables the Comprehensive Management Plan, have been set. The conferees all voted “aye” to the bill with large majorities when it passed through their respective Houses. The final bill was not very different from the ones that passed through both chambers and there should not be much difficulty reconciling the differences.

This is a good example of what it means to “follow the process.” There were no shortcuts or end arounds. Everyone had a chance to speak their mind and in the end, it made for a better document. Congratulations all!

Adopt-A-Class, Year Three

Last night I sent in testimony supporting the Senate Bill that would give authority to the University of Hawai‘i at Hilo’s Mauna Kea Rangers to implement the Comprehensive Management Plan. (See below.)

The Senate passed the bill today, which was good.

But I kept on thinking about our Adopt-A-Class project, and wanting to make sure the Keaukaha Elementary School children can continue to go on excursions. Six hundred dollars adopts a class at Keauakaha Elementary School and sends the students on an excursion they would otherwise not take.

This is the third year we are seeking donations for our Adopt-A-Class program. At our website, you’ll see that a person or group can sponsor the whole excursion for one class ($600), or make a donation of $100 or more and contribute toward that class excursion.

If you can help, please look at the website and tell us which class you’d like to sponsor, and for what amount. There is more information about the process here.

In the meantime, here is the testimony I sent in. Among other things, it explains how we came to start the Adopt-A-Class program in the first place.

Dear Senators,



I am testifying in very strong support of HB 1174, HD3, SD2, the bill that enables us to malama Mauna Kea. Mauna Kea is our kuleana. We know what to do.

I am Richard Ha and I’m a native Hawaiian and a life-long Big Island farmer. We farm 600 acres at Pepeekeo. We have farmed bananas for 25 years and hydroponic vegetables for the last five. Over the years we have produced millions of pounds of food. We sell under the Hamakua Springs brand in the supermarkets. Nearly 70 of us work on the farm. We are concerned with food security and sustainability, especially since we sit out here on islands in the middle of the Pacific.

I would like to share with you how I came to be involved with issues related to Mauna Kea. Three years ago, when I was a new member of the Hawai‘i Island Economic Development Board, the Thirty-Meter Telescope people inquired about siting their telescope on Mauna Kea and the HIEDB formed a special TMT committee. I had strong feelings about the way it should be done: It should be done right! So I volunteered to sit on that committee. Before that, I was just a banana farmer.

When you talk about Mauna Kea you automatically talk about the Hawaiian culture, and when you talk about that, you end up in Keaukaha, the oldest Hawaiian Homes community on the Big Island (75 years). I found that the elementary school there is the center of the Keaukaha community.

I went to see Kumu Lehua Veincent, principal of Keaukaha Elementary School, with what I thought was a good proposal: “The TMT wants to come to the Big Island; what happens if we can convince them to give some kids from the community five, full-ride scholarships to the best schools in the nation?”

Kumu Lehua listened, and then he asked me: “What about the rest?” I could feel my ears getting hot and I felt kind of stupid. Yes, what about the rest?

Also, because the TMT had intentions to do things for the community, I expected the community would be receptive. Instead, I found that the Keaukaha people were very wary, wanting to know: “What do you really want?” They had been promised things many times before.

In the meantime, the TMT board decided to deal directly with UH system. But having met and liked the people in the Keaukaha community and elementary school, I went back again and again to talk story.

One day, I offered to sponsor an excursion to my farm. In the course of that trip, I asked Kumu: “Eh, where you guys go on excursion?” He told me they did not go. “No more money.” Instead, they walked around the neighborhood. I said: “What you mean?” He said, “The bus costs $300 and we don’t have enough money for all the classes.”

I was shocked. How could this be? There were hundreds of millions of dollars’ worth of telescopes on Mauna Kea and there was no evidence of any benefit to Keaukaha, the most Hawaiian of Hawaiian communities?  This no can! We needed to do something.

So, myself, Duane Kanuha, Leslie Lang and Macario decided to copy the Adopt a Child template—where you pay $20 a month and the child sends you a letter and a picture every so often. We decided to do an Adopt A Class project so each class could go on excursions.

We figured $300 for the bus and $300 for entry fees to ‘Imiloa – the world-class Hawaiian culture astronomy museum. So for $600, people could adopt one class and send them on excursion. In four months, we had all the classes going on excursions both semesters.



The idea was contagious. Gordon and Betty Moore heard about the project and donated money to send all classes on the Big Island, from kindergarden to high school – in all public, private and charter schools – to ‘Imiloa. That was nearly three years ago. Now I hear they plan to expand this idea to the San Francisco Bay area.

And due to Kumu Lehua’s leadership, Keaukaha Elementary, a perpetually low-achieving school, had two consecutive years of improvements and came off the No Child Left Behind non-performing list. It was the only elementary school on the Big Island to achieve this distinction. Now they are role models. Imagine that.

Kumu Lehua told me this story: He said a teacher recently came in to interview to see if she could teach at Keaukaha Elementary. He rolled his chair back and told me, “She said it was a career move!”

I have attended at least eight public hearings about Mauna Kea, and many regular meetings of the Keaukaha Community Association, as well as meetings of the Kanaka Council. I have friends on all sides of the issue.

I see myself as a bridge between the shiny shoe crowd and the rubbah slippah crowd. I think that if we all can move toward the center a bit, we can make this work for all of us and especially for future generations.

It is no secret that I think that the TMT can bring benefit to the community. But when I first volunteered for the TMT committee, I insisted it be done right.

So we must malama Mauna Kea before we do anything else. HB 1174, HD3, SD2 helps to enforce the rules that the Comprehensive Management Plan proposes.

I started off by saying that we should not let the perfect be the enemy of the good. When I was a young boy, my dad told me: “There are a thousand reasons why, no can; I only looking for one reason why: CAN!

Richard Ha, President, Hamakua Springs Country Farms

The Mauna Kea Comprehensive Management is Accepted

After listening to two days of testimony, the Board of Land and Natural Resources accepted the Comprehensive Management Plan (CMP) with some conditions. The most significant condition is that the University of Hawai‘i Board of Regents accept responsibility for enforcing the CMP.

There is a requirement to include information from two resource plans that are nearing completion. There is an addition of a decommissioning plan, including upfront funding for returning the site to its original condition. And finally, a plan to delineate access. People did not want access to be taken away. I thought these were very good additions.

The Board of Land and Natural Resources Chair, Laura Thielen, did a very good job of giving everyone a chance to share their thoughts. I was very impressed that they spent two days in Hilo accepting testimony.

University of Hawai‘i President David McClain stayed for the better part of two days. In his introduction, he mentioned the recent Board of Regents declaration of a special relationship with native Hawaiians. This has far-reaching implications.

He went on to make three main points:

  1. That, in the interest of home rule, the University system is committed to the University of Hawai‘i at Hilo being the entity that would manage the CMP.
  2. He committed to funding that would ensure that the CMP could be implemented.
  3. He apologized for the pain and anguish that the native Hawaiian community feels due to the university’s mismanagement prior to 2000.

At the end of the session, Dr. McClain talked about compensation. There is not much that can be done to change the original lease, which gives the IfA a percentage of viewing time as compensation.

He emphasized that the University of Hawai‘i has been providing $2.5 million annually in scholarships to native Hawaiian students. This means that UH is paying the equivalent of 20 percent of what would be $10,000,000 if telescope time were monetized.

From here forward, he said, lease rents for new projects will be determined differently instead of all the telescope time going to UH Manoa. It could include telescope time for the University of Hawai‘i at Hilo, and an amount could go toward community benefits. This is in the early conceptual stages.

The people opposed to the CMP were very organized and people kept on coming through the door to testify. They did a very good job. Out of the 80 or so testifiers overall, I would say that it was evenly split; maybe slightly more in favor than not.

The people who testified in favor were also highly motivated. I have not seen that level of participation before at the eight public hearings that I attended. It clearly made a difference in the decision to accept the CMP.

People were very respectful and tolerant of each other, and this is very encouraging. We all live here on an island in the middle of the ocean and we need to be able to have these discussions, go through the process, come to a conclusion, live with the decision and remain friends. More than anything, I was pleased that we all went through this process together. The result is a better CMP.

Past, Present, Future

Yesterday, in the late afternoon, my daughter and I went by the sign waving event that supporters of the Mauna Kea Comprehensive Management Plan (CMP) held near the Kamehameha statue at the Hilo Bayfront.

IMG_3205

It was an impressive turnout – around 130 people when we got there, I think, many wearing their black “E Malama Mauna Kea” t-shirts. When I looked around I saw business people, labor union folk, scientists that work on Mauna Kea and Hawaiians. What they all have in common is an interest in seeing Mauna Kea taken care of and protected for the future.

Big Island Video News took this video of the sign waving.

IMG_3186

It’s a big deal, this CMP that is being decided on right now, and will have a huge impact. I like that when she’s older I’ll be able to remind my 5-year-old that she was there when people got involved and worked together to take care of something as important as Mauna Kea.

IMG_3194

While we were there I also told her about how that big grassy area we were standing on used to have lots of houses until they were destroyed by a tsunami. I showed her the big mango tree near the Wailoa Center that marks approximately where her great-great-great-great-grandfather Nalimu’s family lived during the second half of the 1800s and well into the 1900s, too. Maybe someday she will stand there with her own child and point out that same history to the next generation.

And now she’ll be able to tell that future child that in 2009 the same ‘aina was also the site of an important demonstration that marked a turning point for how we take care of our Mauna Kea.

We seem to be returning to an era of renewed respect and consideration of Mauna Kea. The ones who came before us would approve.

Sign Waving Tomorrow at the Bayfront; Please Join Us!

Please come to the sign waving in support of the Mauna Kea Comprehensive Management Plan (CMP) on Monday, April 6th between 4 and 6 p.m. We will be in front of the King Kamehameha statue near the Hilo Bayfront. It will be fun!

The first 150 folks will get a container of Hamakua Springs grape tomatoes (one per family).

Coming up with a Comprehensive Management Plan for Mauna Kea has been a long and difficult process. Nevertheless, I think most of us can agree that we have a good start.

The CMP is a living document and it allows people to step up and exercise “our kuleana,” which is to malama Mauna Kea. It is a good plan because it takes special pains to be respectful of the culture, and of the people who practice the culture. Most of all, it is a good plan because we all contributed to it.

• The Office of Hawaiian Affairs issued a Resolution approving the Comprehensive Management Plan.

• The staff of the Board of Land and Natural Resources recommends approval if the Board of Regents accepts responsibility for implementation of the Comprehensive Management  Plan.

• The Association of Hawaiian Civic Clubs recommends approval of the Comprehensive Management Plan.

We hope you will join us at the Bayfront tomorrow afternoon, where we will wave signs in support of the CMP.

Mauna Kea: It’s About The Big Picture

I think it’s really important that I say something now.

I’ve been talking a lot about the Mauna Kea Comprehensive Management Plan, and I want to be very, very clear about one thing:

This is not about “sides.” It’s not about the astronomers or the business people or the Hawaiians or the labor people. It’s not about whose agenda “wins” and whose agenda “loses.”

This is about taking care of Mauna Kea. It’s all about Malama Mauna Kea in a very “big picture” way. The CMP is a process where we are taking everybody’s input and coming up with a plan that takes care of the mountain and looks to the future.

I feel very strongly about this. This is not about any one group of people and what they want. It’s a matter of everybody having their say. I’ve been meeting all the different people who have an interest in Mauna Kea, and they’re all nice people. None of them are the enemy. And I’m not the enemy, either.

We need to aloha everybody – that’s the point. No matter what side of the fence you’re on, we need to aloha you. Because we all have to live here with each other.

When we wave signs on Monday, people will be carrying signs that say “CMP Yes.” But I’m making a sign that will say, “CMP took all of us.” That’s what I’ll say when they interview me. I really feel strongly about this. It’s all of us.

If you’re going to teach the kids anything, you’ve got to teach them that we’re not fighting with each other. We’re going through a process, and it’s a good process. The process is the lesson.

Hear Radio Spots Supporting Mauna Kea CMP / Contest Winners Follow

Many have already committed to waving signs on April 6th in support of the Mauna Kea Comprehensive Management Plan (CMP).

The CMP will be heard before the State Land Board in Hilo on April 8th and 9th.

Richard is encouraging others – including you – to meet them by the Kamehameha Statue at the Hilo Bayfront between 4 and 6 p.m. on Monday, April 6th. He’s even providing a pint of his Hamakua Springs grape tomatoes to each of the first 150 people who arrive (limit one per family).

He helped gather people for some radio spots that are about to hit the airwaves, too. The radio spots were done by five native Hawaiians, all explaining in their own words why they support the Mauna Kea CMP.

“This is what we have to do for the future,” says Richard, of the CMP. “We need to talk to each other, and keep our community tight. It’s not a fight between ourselves. The process is a way for people to say what they need to say, and then we’ll do the best we can for everybody. This is what we have to do.”

“It’s the process,” Richard says. “Everybody is contributing to the process. We’re all in this together.”

Listen to the six short radio clips here:

Audio: William Mokahi Steiner, Dean of the College of Agriculture at the University of Hawai‘i at Hilo 

Audio: Richard Ha, farmer, Hamakua Springs Country Farms

Audio: Patrick Kahawaiola’a, President of the Keaukaha Community Association

Audio: Michael Kaleikini, Manager, Puna Geothermal Venture

Audio: Lehuanani Waipa Ah nee, Young Hawaiian Leader

“There are going to be labor people and business people there who don’t naturally find themselves on the same side, and Hawaiians and every other kind of people,” says Richard. “The labor union guys are telling me, ‘This shouldn’t be the only time we do this; that there will be other issues when we could join together for the common good, and other times we will disagree philosophically, and that’s fine. But that doesn’t mean we can’t agree when it’s mutually beneficial.’

“That’s why I’m so excited about this,” he says.

“It’s really exhilirating when you think about it that way. And that’s why I am encouraging people to bring their kids. It’s a real civics lesson for young kids.”

Final audio clip: Composite of voices supporting the CMP

Please consider joining the sign-wavers – on Monday, April 6 between 4 and 6 p.m. near the Kamehameha Statue on Kamehameha Avenue – to support the Mauna Kea Comprehensive Management Plan.

Wave Signs on April 6th, 4-6 p.m.

There will be a “sign waving” event in support of the  Mauna Kea Comprehensive Management Plan, and the idea of Malama Mauna Kea, on Monday, April 6th, between 4 and 6 p.m.  near the Kamehameha statue at the Hilo bayfront.

We encourage everyone to join us to show the rest of Hawai‘i how things should be done. Bring your kids; this is going to be a historic event.

Hamakua Springs will give one clamshell of grape tomatoes per family to the first 150 people who come to the event.

The Superferry just left town. That was a prime example of how not to do things.

A much better example is what we are working on right now for Mauna Kea – putting together a Comprehensive Management Plan (CMP) that provides for taking care of the mountain, together with giving rangers on the mountain the power to issue tickets to offenders that are not following rules to that end.

Most people agree that to malama Mauna Kea – to take care of Mauna Kea – should be our top priority.

I also hear people saying that Mauna Kea is our kuleana. It is our responsibility. Let us take care.

One reason people have been so angry over the years was that although Mauna Kea was our kuleana here on the Big Island, it was being managed from O‘ahu by the University of Hawai‘i at Manoa.

The control of Mauna Kea by UH Hilo is much better, because control is here on the Big Island now. This allows us to talk story and change things if we need to. People can serve on the Kahu Ku Mauna board or the Mauna Kea Management Board. Because they are not paid, it depends on how much time and commitment one can afford to give.

Another thing people are concerned about is that there is no way to keep people from doing things that are dangerous or destructive. For example, the rangers tell about coming across unresponsive children under the age of 2. The kids cannot talk, so their parents do not know if they are okay in the high altitude or not. They deserve a ticket for being stupid.

People tear down lele, religious altars, and the rangers cannot do anything. People use two-wheel drive and slide off the mountain. Give them tickets; they could hurt other people. That does not even take into consideration the trash that the rangers have to pick up, and the spray-painted graffiti that happens. I say, give them tickets.

Cultural and religious practitioners, though, should be given free access to the mountain. I think that it is not too much to have them talk story with Kahu Ku Mauna, so they know who is legitimate and who is just trying to get around the rules. For example, if someone, as part of the culture, needs to go up the mountain for a sunrise ceremony, I think that there should no problem for that person to go up by 4 a.m. so there is enough time to prepare properly. There should be no question that this is fine. But the guys who are just trying to get around the rules should get a ticket—even if they are Hawaiian.

I testified before the Senate Water, Land, Agriculture and Hawaiian Affairs committee last week on behalf of allowing UH Hilo to do rule-making (i.e., allowing for the Mauna Kea rangers to be able to enforce set rules). There is a safety valve to this—rule making is a public process. No one can make rules without the public having input.

This is not just a UH Hilo power grab. I personally would fight UH to the end if it ever became that.

The provision to set up a fund is not for telescope rents; it is for incidental things having to do with managing the resources on the mountain.

Some people say that DLNR should make the rules and be in control of the management of Mauna Kea. I say, “Be careful about what you wish for.”

I worry about the “game warden” mentality. I would much rather have the ability to talk story with the UH Hilo Rangers and Kahu Ku Mauna. They are here on the Big Island.

I am 1000 percent against people from other islands having a say about our kuleana, Mauna Kea.

I was not there at the recent Mauna Kea Management Board hearing, but I understand that the Kanaka Council and Hanalei Fergerstrom said that they will support the CMP if religion is acknowledged as having special status. I agree with this. But we have to make sure that we are talking about Hawaiian practices.

The CMP is about Malama Mauna Kea. I think that we all can agree that this is the most important thing and needs to be done before anything else.

Specific projects will need to stand on their own merits. They will have to follow the CMP and also do an EIS.

The Superferry did not even have a Comprehensive Management Plan. Then they also went around the EIS process. They gambled, and they lost big.

All of us, pro and con, have added to the process of Malama Mauna Kea. We are not on different sides; we are all in this together!  Mahalo, everyone!

Attend the CMP Hearing (Apr. 8th and 9th) and Malama Mauna Kea!

Adze Quarry Search 003
Spray-painted graffiti at adze quarry  

Mauna kea trafficTraffic jam on Mauna Kea

Lele vandalismVandalized lele (altar)

Why support the Comprehensive Management Plan for Mauna Kea? Because currently, the UH Hilo/Office of Mauna Kea Management rangers have no power to enforce problems with:

• Cultural resource damage
• Natural resource degradation issues
• Public health issues
• Safety issues

The CMP does not mean:

• new gates on the mountain
• a curb on constitutionally guaranteed religious and gathering rights (except for public safety/public health reasons)

Please attend the Land Board hearing on April 8th and 9th in support of the Comprehensive Management Plan.

Where: Hilo Hawaiian Hotel
When: April 8th and 9th, from 9 a.m. to 9 p.m. both days